Get Updates on New Texas Business Guides

Mediation is a voluntary negotiation process facilitated by a neutral third-party mediator. Unlike arbitration or litigation where a decision-maker imposes a resolution, mediation allows parties to control the outcome through facilitated negotiation. Understanding the mediation process helps businesses participate effectively in this common form of dispute resolution.

What Is Mediation?

Mediation involves a neutral mediator who helps disputing parties explore settlement options and negotiate resolution.

Key characteristics:

• Voluntary settlement: Parties cannot be forced to settle
• Facilitated negotiation: Mediator helps parties communicate and negotiate
• No imposed decision: Mediator does not decide the case
• Confidential process: Communications privileged under Texas law
• Party control: Parties retain control over outcome

The Mediation Process

The Mediator's Role

What Mediators Do

Facilitation functions:

• Facilitate communication between parties
• Help identify underlying interests and concerns
• Assist in generating settlement options
• Provide reality testing about litigation risks
• Maintain neutrality throughout process
• Manage process and keep discussions productive

What Mediators Do NOT Do

Limits on mediator role:

• Do not decide the case or impose solutions
• Do not act as judge or arbitrator
• Do not represent either party
• Do not provide legal advice to parties
• Cannot force parties to settle
• Cannot disclose confidential caucus information

Mediation Confidentiality and Privilege

Texas Mediation Privilege

Scope of privilege:

• Communications during mediation are confidential
• Cannot be disclosed in litigation
• Cannot be used as evidence
• Applies to all mediation participants
• Mediator cannot be called as witness

Exceptions to confidentiality:

• All parties agree to waive confidentiality
• Settlement agreement (if reached)
• Threats of violence or criminal activity
• Professional misconduct by mediator
• Abuse or neglect of child or elderly person

Benefits of Confidentiality

Encourages candid discussions:

• Parties can explore settlement without litigation risk
• Can make settlement offers without admissions
• Allows discussion of weaknesses without prejudice
• Promotes realistic evaluation of case

Court-Ordered Mediation

Many Texas courts order mediation before allowing cases to proceed to trial.

When Courts Order Mediation

Timing:

• Often ordered early in case after initial pleadings
• May be required before trial setting
• Can be ordered at any stage of litigation

Requirements:

• Parties must attend mediation
• Must participate in good faith
• Decision-makers with settlement authority should attend
• Failure to attend may result in sanctions

Selecting Mediator

Selection methods:

• Parties agree on mediator selection
• Court appoints from approved list if parties cannot agree
• Mediators must meet qualifications (training, experience)
• Many are experienced attorneys or retired judges

Mediation Costs

Fee arrangements:

• Parties typically share mediator fees equally
• Mediator fees vary (commonly $200-$500+ per hour)
• Typical mediation: half-day to full-day session
• Each party responsible for own attorney fees

Settlement Agreements

Creating Enforceable Settlements

Essential elements:

• Clear terms agreed upon by parties
• Reduced to writing
• Signed by parties or authorized representatives
• Specific and unambiguous language

Common settlement provisions:

• Payment terms (amount, timing, method)
• Release of claims
• Dismissal of pending litigation
• Confidentiality provisions
• Non-disparagement clauses
• Future relationship terms if applicable

Enforcing Settlement Agreements

Enforcement mechanisms:

• Settlement agreement is enforceable contract
• Can be enforced through breach of contract action
• May be incorporated into court order
• Court can enforce terms and award damages for breach

Characteristics Often Associated with Mediation

Party Control

• Parties retain control over outcome
• No decision imposed by third party
• Can accept or reject settlement proposals
• Settlement only occurs if both parties agree

Relationship Preservation

• Less adversarial than trial
• Can preserve ongoing business relationships
• Focuses on interests rather than legal positions
• May allow continued business dealings

Creative Solutions

• Not limited to legal remedies available in court
• Can address business interests beyond legal rights
• May include non-monetary terms
• Flexible settlements tailored to parties' needs

Settlement Outcomes

• Mediation frequently results in settlement or narrowing of disputed issues
• Unsuccessful mediations often provide value by clarifying positions
• May facilitate later settlement even if immediate resolution doesn't occur
• Provides realistic assessment of case value and litigation risks

Preparing for Successful Mediation

Preparation steps commonly taken:

• Analyze case strengths and weaknesses realistically
• Determine settlement authority and range
• Prepare mediation statement if required
• Gather key documents
• Ensure decision-maker will attend
• Consider other party's perspective and interests
• Develop settlement proposals and alternatives
• Understand litigation costs and timeline as alternative